An array of stud earrings curved around a tan stone on a grey background.

Gifts $500 and Under

Find something exceptional to give (or receive) from our curated collection of fine jewelry, nesting and stacking bands, and sparkling new arrivals, all under $500.

$500 and Under

Stone
White Diamond
Champagne Diamond
Black Diamond
Gemstone
Shape
Silhouette
Style
Mix & Match
Studs
Hoops
Nesting
Stacking
Plain
Classic
Diamond Accent
Price
Size
Category
Bands
Earrings
Necklaces
Collection
Chevron
Sheaves
Serpent
Hazeline
Bea & Theda
Rosette
Wheat
Pointe
Talisman
Licol
"Anna Sheffield" gift card on a adobe orange color rectangle.

Digital Gift Card

Starting at $100
A white candle with a gold lid and the handle is shaped in the logo of Anna Sheffield.

Anna Sheffield Candle

Natural Fine Fragrance

$220
"Anna Sheffield Fine Jewelry Cleaner" in a small jar with clear liquid.

Fine Jewelry Cloth & Cleaner Set

$19
"Anna Sheffield Gentle Fine Jewelry Cleaner" in a small jar with blue liquid.

Gentle Fine Jewelry Cloth & Cleaner Set

$19
A 18mm charm with interlocking monogrammed engraved on the front set in yellow gold on a yellow gold chain.

Engraved Interlocking Monogram Disk Charm Pendant

14k Yellow Gold

Starting at $950
A 14mm plain gold charm set in yellow gold on a yellow gold chain., 14mm

Classic Disk Charm Pendant

14k Yellow Gold

Starting at $750
A small hand pendant in yellow gold with a white diamond accent stone on a yellow gold chain.

Petit Hand Talisman Necklace

14k Yellow Gold & White Diamond

Starting at $850
A medium serpent pendant in yellow gold on a yellow gold chain., Without Diamonds

Petit Serpent Talisman Necklace

Yellow Gold

Starting at $495
An image with twelve stud earrings with all zodiac signs.

Zodiac Studs

14k Yellow Gold & White Diamond

$275 - $550
Ready to Ship
A pair of earrings with three white diamonds set in the shape of an arrow set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold A pair of earrings with three white diamonds set in the shape of an arrow set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold 1 A pair of earrings with three white diamonds set in the shape of an arrow set in yellow gold on earring angled., Yellow Gold 2 Female ear wearing Bea Arrow Stud Earring - 14k Gold & White Diamond 3 A light-complextion model with three stud earrings with diamonds., White Gold, Rose Gold, Yellow Gold 4

Bea Arrow Stud Earring

14k Yellow Gold & White Diamond

$575 - $1,150
Select Options Ready to Ship
A pair of tiny grey spinel center stone earrings with a halo of white diamond set in rose gold., Rose Gold A pair of tiny grey spinel center stone earrings with a halo of white diamond set in rose gold., Rose Gold 1 A single tiny grey spinel center stone earring with a halo of white diamond set in rose gold. 2 A pair of tiny grey spinel center stone earrings with a halo of white diamond set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold 3 A pair of tiny grey spinel center stone earrings with a halo of white diamond set in yellow gold one earring angled. 4 Female ear wearing Rosette Stud Earring (Tiny) - 14k Gold, Grey Spinel & Champagne Diamonds 5
Metal
Rose Gold
Yellow Gold

Rosette Stud Earring (Tiny)

14k Gold, Grey Spinel & Champagne Diamonds

$450 - $900
A pair of hoops with a line of emeralds set in yellow gold.

Licol Hoop

Yellow Gold & Emeralds

$550 - $1,100
Ready to Ship
A pair of hoops with a line of black diamonds set in yellow gold.

Licol Hoop

Yellow Gold & Black Diamonds

$575 - $1,150
A pair of hoops with a line of champagne diamonds set in yellow gold. A pair of hoops with a line of champagne diamonds set in yellow gold. 1 A single earrings with a white trillion set above a line of white diamond pave set in yellow gold on the top of a light-complexion models ear at the base of the ear are two hoop earrings and a diamond dusted line stud. 2 Licol Hoop - Yellow Gold & Champagne Diamonds 3 A pair of hoops with a line of champagne diamonds set in yellow gold one earring is angled. 4

Licol Hoop

Yellow Gold & Champagne Diamonds

$550 - $1,100
A solid gold pair of huggie hoops set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold A solid gold pair of huggie hoops set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold 1 Side view of a solid gold pair of huggie hoops set in yellow gold. 2 A solid gold pair of huggie hoops set in rose gold., Rose Gold 3 One side and one straight on view of a solid gold pair of huggie hoops set in rose gold. 4 A solid gold pair of huggie hoops set in white gold., White Gold 5 Wheat Hoop - 14k Gold 6
Metal
Yellow Gold
Rose Gold
White Gold

Wheat Hoop

14k Gold

$375 - $750
Select Options Ready to Ship
A pair of grey diamond dusted curve earrings set in rose gold both earrings angled., Rose Gold A pair of grey diamond dusted curve earrings set in rose gold both earrings angled., Rose Gold 1 Female ear wearing Wheat Half Eternity Climber - 14k Gold & Grey Diamonds 2 14k gold eari climber by anna sheffield 3 A pair of grey diamond dusted curve earrings set in rose gold both earrings on their side., Rose Gold 4 A pair of grey diamond dusted curve earrings set in yellow gold both earrings angled., Yellow Gold 5 A pair of grey diamond dusted curve earrings set in yellow gold one earring angled., Yellow Gold 6 A pair of grey diamond dusted curve earrings set in white gold both earrings angled., White Gold 7 A single grey diamond dusted curve earring set in white gold., White Gold 8
Metal
Rose Gold
Yellow Gold
White Gold

Wheat Half Eternity Climber

14k Gold & Grey Diamonds

$645 - $1,290
A pair of white diamond dusted curve earrings set in yellow gold both earrings angled., Yellow Gold A pair of white diamond dusted curve earrings set in yellow gold both earrings angled., Yellow Gold 1 Female ear wearing Wheat Half Eternity Climber - 14k Gold & White Diamonds 2 14k gold eari climber by anna sheffield 3 A pair of white diamond dusted curve earrings set in yellow gold both earrings on their side., Yellow Gold 4 A single white diamond dusted curve earring set in rose gold., Rose Gold 5

Wheat Half Eternity Climber

14k Gold & White Diamonds

$710 - $1,420
A pair of earrings with four black diamonds with a chain connecting to the ear back set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold A pair of earrings with four black diamonds with a chain connecting to the ear back set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold 1 A pair of earrings with four black diamonds with a chain connecting to the ear back set in rose gold., Rose Gold 2 Side view of a pair of earrings with four black diamonds with a chain connecting to the ear back set in rose gold., Rose Gold 3 A single earring with four white diamonds with a chain connecting to the ear back set in yellow gold on a light-complexion ear., White Gold, Rose Gold, Yellow Gold 4 A single earring with four black diamonds with a chain connecting to the ear back set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold 5 A pair of earrings with four black diamonds with a chain connecting to the ear back set in white gold., White Gold 6
Metal
Yellow Gold
Rose Gold
White Gold

Pointe Harness Earring

14k Gold & Black Diamond

$415 - $830
A pair of earrings with four white diamonds with a chain connecting to the ear back set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold A pair of earrings with four white diamonds with a chain connecting to the ear back set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold 1 Side view of a pair of earrings with four white diamonds with a chain connecting to the ear back set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold 2 A single earring with four white diamonds with a chain connecting to the ear back set in yellow gold on a light-complexion ear., White Gold, Rose Gold, Yellow Gold 3

Pointe Harness Earring

14k Gold & White Diamond

$490 - $980
A serpent band with grey diamonds for eyes set in sterling silver.

Serpent Band

Sterling Silver & Grey Diamond

$450
A monogrammed signet ring with an "A" on the front and two grey diamond accents on either side and set in sterling silver., Letter A

Monogrammed Signet Ring

Sterling Silver

$425
A chevron shaped band in solid gold set in rose gold., Rose Gold A chevron shaped band in solid gold set in rose gold., Rose Gold 1 A chevron shaped band in solid gold set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold 2 A chevron shaped band in solid gold set in white gold., White Gold 3 Three chevron shaped band in solid gold set in rose, yellow, and white gold. 4
Metal
Rose Gold
Yellow Gold
White Gold

Delicate Chevron Band

14k Gold

$750
Select Options Ready to Ship
A tiny straight band with leaf like definition set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold A tiny straight band with leaf like definition set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold 1 A tiny straight band with leaf like definition set in rose gold., Rose Gold 2 A tiny straight band with leaf like definition set in white gold., White Gold 3 Two solid gold wedding bands one in white gold engraved with “Diamond” on the inside and one in yellow gold with “Moon + Stars” engraved on the inside. 4
Metal
Yellow Gold
Rose Gold
White Gold

Tiny Sheaves Band

14k Gold

Starting at $495
Select Options Ready to Ship
Half round band in 4mm, 14k yellow gold, classic Half round band in 4mm, 14k yellow gold, classic 1 Classic Half Round Band - 14k Gold or Platinum 2 A 2mm classic round band set in rose gold., Rose Gold, Classic 3 A 2mm classic round band set in yellow gold. 4 A 2mm classic round band set in white gold. 5 A 2mm classic round band with brushed finish set in rose gold., Rose Gold, Brushed 6 A 2mm classic round band with brushed finish set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold, Brushed 7 A 2mm classic round band with brushed finish set in white gold., White Gold, Brushed 8 A 2mm classic round band with hammered finish set in rose gold., Rose Gold, Hammered 9 A 2mm classic round band with hammered finish set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold, Hammered 10 A 2mm classic round band with hammered finish set in white gold., White Gold, Hammered 11 Classic Half Round Band - 14k Gold or Platinum 12 Classic Half Round Band - 14k Gold or Platinum 13 Classic Half Round Band - 14k Gold or Platinum 14 Classic Half Round Band - 14k Gold or Platinum 15 Classic Half Round Band - 14k Gold or Platinum 16 Classic Half Round Band - 14k Gold or Platinum 17 Classic Half Round Band - 14k Gold or Platinum 18 Classic Half Round band by Anna Sheffield. Yellow Gold, Brushed 19 Classic Half Round Band - 14k Gold or Platinum 20 Half round band in 4mm, 14k rose gold, brushed 21 Classic Half Round Band - 14k Gold or Platinum 22 Half round band in 4mm, 14k white gold, brushed 23 Classic Half Round Band - 14k Gold or Platinum 24 Classic Half Round Band - 14k Gold or Platinum 25 Classic Half Round Band - 14k Gold or Platinum 26 Classic Half Round band by Anna Sheffield. Rose Gold, Classic 27 Classic Half Round band by Anna Sheffield. White Gold, Classic 28 Two solid gold wedding bands one in white gold engraved with “Diamond” on the inside and one in yellow gold with “Moon + Stars” engraved on the inside. 29
Metal
Yellow Gold
Rose Gold
White Gold
Platinum

Classic Half Round Band

14k Gold or Platinum

Starting at $480
A 1.5mm flat band set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold A 1.5mm flat band set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold 1 A 1.5mm flat band set in rose gold., Rose Gold 2 A 1.5mm flat band set in white gold., White Gold 3 A 1.5mm flat band with a hammered finished set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold 4 A 1.5mm flat band with a hammered finished set in rose gold., Rose Gold 5 A 1.5mm flat band with a hammered finished set in white gold., White Gold 6
Metal
Yellow Gold
Rose Gold
White Gold

Hazeline Band

14k Gold, 1.5mm

Starting at $450
A black candle holder holding a yellow twisted candle to symbolize a twin flame with a brass candle snuffer next to it.

Twin Flame Set

$65
A brass candle holder holding a tall black candlestick with a pack of matches in evil eye packaging next to it.

Protective Flame Set

$48
A pair of tiny emerald center stone earrings with a halo of champagne diamond set in sterling silver.

Pair Rosette Stud Earring (Tiny)

Sterling Silver, Emerald & Champagne Diamond
Was $550

$850
A 14mm charm with the Aries zodiac sign set in sterling silver on a sterling silver chain.

Zodiac Charm Necklace

Sterling Silver

$350
Ready to Ship
A single five grey diamond pointe earring stud set in yellow gold.

Single Pave Pointe Stud, Medium (SINGLE)

Was $365

$220
Ready to Ship
A ring with an oval shape blue topaz center stone surrounded by a champagne diamond pave halo set in sterling silver.

Pavé Amulet Ring (Size 3.75)

Was $975

$250
A 4mm flat edge band set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold A 4mm flat edge band set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold 1 A 5mm flat edge band set in white gold., White Gold 2 Two solid gold wedding bands one in white gold engraved with “Diamond” on the inside and one in yellow gold with “Moon + Stars” engraved on the inside. 3 A 4mm flat edge band with a brushed finish set in white gold. 4 A 5mm flat edge band with a brushed finished set in yellow gold. 5 A 4mm flat edge band in rose gold 6 A 5mm flat edge band with brushed finished set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold 7 A 5mm flat edge band with brushed finished set in white gold., White Gold 8 A 5mm flat edge band with brushed finished set in rose gold., Rose Gold 9 A 5mm flat edge band set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold 10 A 5mm flat edge band set in rose gold., Rose Gold 11 A 4mm flat edge band set in rose gold., Rose Gold 12 A 4mm flat edge band set in white gold., White Gold 13 A 4mm flat edge band with a brushed finish set in rose gold., Rose Gold 14 A 4mm flat edge band with a brushed finish set in white gold., White Gold 15 A 4mm flat edge band with a brushed finish set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold 16
Metal
Yellow Gold
Rose Gold
White Gold
Platinum

Flat Edge Band

14k Gold or Platinum

Starting at $590
Rosette Stud Earring (Tiny) - Sterling Silver, Grey Spinel & Champagne Diamond Was <s>$650</s> Rosette Stud Earring (Tiny) - Sterling Silver, Grey Spinel & Champagne Diamond Was <s>$650</s> 1 Rosette Stud Earring (Tiny) - Sterling Silver, Grey Spinel & Champagne Diamond Was <s>$650</s> 2

Rosette Stud Earring (Tiny)

Sterling Silver, Grey Spinel & Champagne Diamond Was $650

$155 - $310
A 14mm charm with the Aries zodiac sign set in sterling silver on a sterling silver chain.

ARIES Zodiac Charm Necklace

Sterling Silver
Was $350

$225
Ready to Ship
A 14mm charm with the Leo zodiac sign set in sterling silver on a sterling silver chain.

LEO Zodiac Charm Necklace

Sterling Silver
Was $350

$225
Ready to Ship
A 14mm charm with the Virgo zodiac sign set in sterling silver on a sterling silver chain.

VIRGO Zodiac Charm Necklace

Sterling Silver
Was $350

$225
Ready to Ship
A 14mm charm with the Libra zodiac sign set in sterling silver on a sterling silver chain.

LIBRA Zodiac Charm Necklace

Sterling Silver
Was $350

$225
Ready to Ship
A 14mm charm with the Scorpio zodiac sign set in sterling silver on a sterling silver chain.

SCORPIO Zodiac Charm Necklace

Sterling Silver
Was $350

$225
Ready to Ship
A 14mm charm with the Aquarius zodiac sign set in sterling silver on a sterling silver chain.

AQUARIUS Zodiac Charm Necklace

Sterling Silver
Was $350

$225
Ready to Ship
A 14mm charm with the Pisces zodiac sign set in sterling silver on a sterling silver chain.

PISCES Zodiac Charm Necklace

Sterling Silver
Was $350

$225
Ready to Ship
A pair of Gemini stud earrings set in yellow gold with a white diamond accent stone with one earring angled.

GEMINI Zodiac Studs

Was $275

$150 - $300
Ready to Ship
A gold earring virgo zodiac stud with a white diamond on a white background

SINGLE VIRGO Zodiac Stud

Was $275

$150 - $300
Gold sagittarius zodiac stud earring with a diamond on a white background

SINGLE Sagittarius Zodiac Stud

Was $275

$150 - $300
Ready to Ship
A pair of Capricorn stud earrings set in yellow gold with a white diamond accent stone with one earring angled.

Capricorn Zodiac Studs

Was $275

$150 - $300
Ready to Ship
A pair of Pisces stud earrings set in yellow gold with a white diamond accent stone with one earring angled.

Pisces Zodiac Studs

Was $275

$150 - $300
Back to top

Gifts Under $500

Discover bands, earrings, and bracelets curated for Holiday gifting to loved ones (or yourself).  14k gold stacking rings with classic or modern details are the perfect addition to a ceremonial or fine jewelry band stack for both men and women.  Emeralds, Sapphires, Rubies, and Diamonds are all available in mix & match earring styles for under $500. 

All orders are delivered express with complimentary 2-day shipping. All made-to-order item purchases must be placed by November 22nd to receive in time for the Holidays.

Our New York and Los Angeles locations offer appointments with our fine jewelry experts for ceremonial, holiday or special occasion gifting. Appointments can be made online here.