An array of stud earrings curved around a tan stone on a grey background.

Gifts $500 and Under

Find something exceptional to give (or receive) from our curated collection of in-stock fine jewelry, all under $500.

In Stock $500 and Under

Stone
White Diamond
Champagne Diamond
Grey Diamond
Gemstone
Shape
Silhouette
Style
Mix & Match
Studs
Hoops
Nesting
Stacking
Plain
Classic
Diamond Accent
Price
Size
Category
Bands
Earrings
Necklaces
Collection
Chevron
Sheaves
Bea & Theda
Wheat
Talisman
Zodiac
Licol
An image with twelve stud earrings with all zodiac signs.

Zodiac Studs

14k Yellow Gold & White Diamond

$275 - $550
Ready to Ship
A 14mm charm with the Aries zodiac sign set in sterling silver on a sterling silver chain.

Zodiac Charm Necklace

Sterling Silver

$350
Ready to Ship
A tiny straight band with leaf like definition set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold A tiny straight band with leaf like definition set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold 1 A tiny straight band with leaf like definition set in rose gold., Rose Gold 2 A tiny straight band with leaf like definition set in white gold., White Gold 3 Two solid gold wedding bands one in white gold engraved with “Diamond” on the inside and one in yellow gold with “Moon + Stars” engraved on the inside. 4
Metal
Yellow Gold
Rose Gold
White Gold

Tiny Sheaves Band

14k Gold

Starting at $495
Select Options Ready to Ship
A white candle with a gold lid and the handle is shaped in the logo of Anna Sheffield.

Anna Sheffield Candle

Natural Fine Fragrance

$220
"Anna Sheffield" gift card on a adobe orange color rectangle.

Digital Gift Card

Starting at $100
A chevron shaped band in solid gold set in rose gold., Rose Gold A chevron shaped band in solid gold set in rose gold., Rose Gold 1 A chevron shaped band in solid gold set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold 2 A chevron shaped band in solid gold set in white gold., White Gold 3 Three chevron shaped band in solid gold set in rose, yellow, and white gold. 4
Metal
Rose Gold
Yellow Gold
White Gold

Delicate Chevron Band

14k Gold

$750
Select Options Ready to Ship
A pair of hoops with a line of emeralds set in yellow gold.

Licol Hoop

Yellow Gold & Emeralds

$550 - $1,100
Ready to Ship
A solid gold pair of huggie hoops set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold A solid gold pair of huggie hoops set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold 1 Side view of a solid gold pair of huggie hoops set in yellow gold. 2 A solid gold pair of huggie hoops set in rose gold., Rose Gold 3 One side and one straight on view of a solid gold pair of huggie hoops set in rose gold. 4 A solid gold pair of huggie hoops set in white gold., White Gold 5 Wheat Hoop - 14k Gold 6
Metal
Yellow Gold
Rose Gold
White Gold

Wheat Hoop

14k Gold

$375 - $750
Select Options Ready to Ship
A gold pair of huggie hoops with champagne diamonds set in rose gold., Rose Gold A gold pair of huggie hoops with champagne diamonds set in rose gold., Rose Gold 1 Side view of a gold pair of huggie hoops with champagne diamonds set in rose gold. 2 A gold pair of huggie hoops with champagne diamonds set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold 3 Wheat Hoop - 14k Gold & Champagne Diamonds 4
Metal
Rose Gold
Yellow Gold

Wheat Hoop

14k Gold & Champagne Diamonds

$525 - $1,050
Select Options Ready to Ship
A pair of earrings with three white diamonds set in the shape of an arrow set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold A pair of earrings with three white diamonds set in the shape of an arrow set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold 1 A pair of earrings with three white diamonds set in the shape of an arrow set in yellow gold on earring angled., Yellow Gold 2 Female ear wearing Bea Arrow Stud Earring - 14k Gold & White Diamond 3 A light-complextion model with three stud earrings with diamonds., White Gold, Rose Gold, Yellow Gold 4

Bea Arrow Stud Earring

14k Yellow Gold & White Diamond

$575 - $1,150
Select Options Ready to Ship
A 14mm charm with the Aries zodiac sign set in sterling silver on a sterling silver chain.

ARIES Zodiac Charm Necklace

Sterling Silver
Was $350

$225
Ready to Ship
A 14mm charm with the Leo zodiac sign set in sterling silver on a sterling silver chain.

LEO Zodiac Charm Necklace

Sterling Silver
Was $350

$225
Ready to Ship
A 14mm charm with the Virgo zodiac sign set in sterling silver on a sterling silver chain.

VIRGO Zodiac Charm Necklace

Sterling Silver
Was $350

$225
Ready to Ship
A 14mm charm with the Libra zodiac sign set in sterling silver on a sterling silver chain.

LIBRA Zodiac Charm Necklace

Sterling Silver
Was $350

$225
Ready to Ship
A 14mm charm with the Scorpio zodiac sign set in sterling silver on a sterling silver chain.

SCORPIO Zodiac Charm Necklace

Sterling Silver
Was $350

$225
Ready to Ship
A 14mm charm with the Aquarius zodiac sign set in sterling silver on a sterling silver chain.

AQUARIUS Zodiac Charm Necklace

Sterling Silver
Was $350

$225
Ready to Ship
A 14mm charm with the Pisces zodiac sign set in sterling silver on a sterling silver chain.

PISCES Zodiac Charm Necklace

Sterling Silver
Was $350

$225
Ready to Ship
A pair of Gemini stud earrings set in yellow gold with a white diamond accent stone with one earring angled.

GEMINI Zodiac Studs

Was $275

$150 - $300
Ready to Ship
Gold sagittarius zodiac stud earring with a diamond on a white background

SINGLE Sagittarius Zodiac Stud

Was $275

$150 - $300
Ready to Ship
A pair of Capricorn stud earrings set in yellow gold with a white diamond accent stone with one earring angled.

Capricorn Zodiac Studs

Was $275

$150 - $300
Ready to Ship
Back to top

In-Stock $500 and Under

Discover in-stock bands, earrings, necklaces, and bracelets curated for Holiday gifting to loved ones (or yourself). 14k gold stacking rings with classic or modern details are the perfect addition to a ceremonial or fine jewelry band stack for both men and women. Emeralds, Sapphires, Rubies, and Diamonds are all available in mix & match earring styles for under $500. 

Our New York and Los Angeles locations offer appointments with our fine jewelry experts for ceremonial, holiday or special occasion gifting. Appointments can be made online here.