Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

Our Materials and Resources

What are our sustainability practices and how do we define ethical diamonds?

Anna Sheffield Fine Jewelry is committed to the highest degree of sustainable, ethical and responsible practice. All sourcing and production is done in accordance with these principles, including the use of recycled metals and conflict-free stones, as well as rare and exceptional reclaimed and antique diamonds. All modern diamonds used in ceremonial rings are compliant with the Kimberley Process via their source, and GIA-certified diamonds are provided upon request.

Personalization & Customization

Create a piece that is uniquely yours with the help of one of our Fine Jewelry experts. We offer a range of custom options, from bespoke to one-of-a-kind designs.

What is bespoke?

Every piece in our collection can be specially made-to-order and modified down to the smallest detail. Personalize one of our signature styles by selecting your preferred stone—color, shape, size and cut. Choose from a range of metal alloys and embellish with delicate details—such as diamond pavé and hand engraving. Our team is on-hand to guide you through our collections and reveal the unique qualities that give these precious materials their distinctive beauty.

How do I begin the bespoke process?

  1. Explore our collection. 
  2. Select your favorite pieces, identifying them by name, design and style (eg. solitaire, threestone, diamond halo, antique diamond). 
  3. Note any changes, additions or special details you’d like to include in your bespoke design.
  4. Contact us to arrange your bespoke consultation. Over an appointment with one of our associates, you’ll learn about diamonds and our procurement process, time lines, ring sizing, and the final details such as delivery options.

If you happen to be in the New York City area, you’re welcome to book your appointment in-store. Feeling spontaneous? Simply walk in and speak with an associate during business hours.

What if I want an original custom design?

Create a one-of-a-kind ceremonial ring or future heirloom with the help of our Fine Jewelry experts. Our custom approach is tailored to you, and grounded in your unique love story. Begin the experience with a private consultation with Anna, and learn about our original creative process—from design inspiration and diamond education to metal selection and stone sourcing. We know that this process may be unfamiliar to many of our customers, and are committed to providing the highest levels of service, consideration and care. Custom commissions are by appointment only; please call 212 925 7010 to make your appointment today.

Can I incorporate an heirloom stone?

We love working with Heirloom stones, but need to first ensure that the stone is suitable. We ask that clients provide a few specific details to make this determination; quality and condition will inform if and how a stone may be used, while the shape, color and cut relate to the possible design. Please send a photograph and as much information on the stone as possible, including carat size, millimeter dimensions and GIA certification if applicable.

Please have your stone appraised prior to your appointment to determine its valuation.

Do you work with clients remotely?

We’re happy to work remotely, and take pride in serving people all over the world with both bespoke and custom orders. E-mail or call us at 212 925 7010 to arrange a consultation via phone or Skype.

Please allow 2-5 days for us to respond as custom queries require extra time and attention.

How quickly can my jewelry get made? Do you provide rush service?

Our bespoke and custom pieces can usually be made to order in 4–6 weeks from the date the order is finalized. We provide rush services whenever possible, though fees may apply.

Do you provide engraving services?

We provide hand engraving services. Engraving typically adds five to ten business days to standard order fulfillment. Please note all engraved pieces will be final sale.


What is your shipping method?

We ship all domestic parcels via UPS. Orders valued at above $300 receive complementary shipping via UPS 2 Day. Other shipping options include domestic Next Day shipping ($75), domestic Standard Shipping ($20), and International Priority via FedEx ($125, does not include duties and taxes). All of our pieces are fully insured while in transit, and must be signed for when received.

Do you ship internationally?

We serve customers around the world via FedEx International Priority. Shipping times vary, depending on the destination country, and take approximately 3–15 business days. All pieces are fully insured during transit time and are subject to all duties and taxes imposed by the destination country.

How do I know if my order is in-stock or made-to-order?

Product availability and production timelines are listed on the product page for the item. Pieces that are in-stock will ship in 1-3 business days. If you are looking for an Engagement Ring that is in-stock, please see our In Stock Engagement Rings collection. Additionally, we have collections for in-stock Bands and in-stock Fine Jewelry.

Returns, Exchanges & Cancellations

What is your return policy and how can I make a return or exchange?

If you are not satisfied with your purchase, please email our customer service department at Your request for return will be answered by our customer service team within 1-3 business days, and will provide further instructions for sending in your return.

All orders will incur a 10% restocking fee (not to exceed $500) for returned items. Items being exchanged for another item will not incur the 10% restocking fee. 

All Fine Jewelry purchased from our Future Heritage Fund collection and Terra Firma collections are subject to the restocking fee.

Is there a Restocking Fee?

All orders will incur a 10% restocking fee (not to exceed $500) for returned items. Items being exchanged for another item will not incur the 10% restocking fee.

How can I ship my return or exchange back to Anna Sheffield?

After your return has been confirmed via email with our sales team, please ship your return or exchange with its original packaging via a parcel service that is traceable and insured. We highly recommend insuring your parcel as we are not responsible for returns lost in the mail. The client is responsible for all shipping costs. Please allow 1-3 business days for us to process your return upon receipt. Original shipping charges (if applicable) will not be refunded.

How long will it take to receive my refund?

Please allow 1-3 business days for us to process your return upon receipt. Original shipping charges (if applicable) will not be refunded. Please allow 3-10 business days for the credit to appear on your account. Purchases made using Venmo may also take up to 5 business days.

Which items are final sale?

Customized, engraved, and Bespoke jewelry orders are final sale. Gift Cards, accessories, and home goods such as jewelry cleaners, books, and pottery are final sale.

I just placed my order but would like to cancel it. How can I do that?

Please email our team at to request a cancellation. Any cancellations of standard orders must be done within 2 business days of order to avoid any additional fees or charges.

Warranties & Repairs

Do you provide warranties?

We provide a one-year warranty on our jewelry from the date of delivery. Your warranty includes:

  • One complimentary resizing on rings and bands as styles allow.
  • Repair or replacement due to a defect in materials or workmanship.
  • Your warranty does not cover wear during normal usage under the conditions for which it was designed, neglect or accidental damage.
  • Repairs or service by another jeweler will void your warranty.

We also offer a six month limited warranty on our turquoise, emerald, pearl and opal jewelry, as softer stones require more care than diamond and other gemstone pieces. Please read about our suggested care for your fine jewelry here.

For additional information or if any issues arise in the first year, please reach out to the salesperson who helped you, or email us at

In or out of warranty, we are always happy to assist you with your resizing and repairs. You can work directly with the salesperson who helped you previously, or start a conversation to get an estimate here.

How to begin a repair?

Please send all repair and resize requests to our team at Include the name on the order and desired work to be completed on your item. Our team will respond in 2-5 business days with instructions on how to ship your item back to us and the timeline for the repair work to be completed.


Do you offer any financing options?

We provide three financing options; Bread, Klarna, and Shop Pay.

Appraisals & Insurance

Can I get an appraisal or evaluation report?

We are happy to provide you with an evaluation report once your purchase is complete. Evaluation reports document the retail value of each piece for insurance purposes. Please note, however, that an evaluation report is not an appraisal. A formal appraisal requires an independent assessment by a certified appraiser, and is unfortunately not a service that we can offer.

Do you provide insurance?

We always recommend that you insure your jewelry, but do not offer insurance through Anna Sheffield.

Our shipments are fully insured while in transit, but we do not provide coverage for your purchases once they have been delivered. We always recommend you insure your pieces to protect against loss, theft or damage, and suggest our partners at Jewelers Mutual for the safe keeping of your fine jewelry. If you have additional questions, one of our sales associates will be happy to help you.

Connect with Us

We’d love to hear from you